Balboa Island
Property Management

Owning a rental on Balboa Island is a prestigious investment, but the logistics are unique. Whether you own a historic cottage on the Little Island or a waterfront custom home on the Big Island, preserving these assets requires specialized care. The marine environment is brutal on exteriors, and navigating vendor access during peak season can be a nightmare. Good Life Property Management handles the specific demands of the Island. We coordinate “salt-proof” maintenance, manage strict parking and noise compliance, and secure high-net-worth tenants who seek the quiet charm of island living—not a summer party house.

Our Balboa Island Property Management Services

Overview

About Balboa Island

Balboa Island is a harborside community in Newport Beach, California. As you’d expect from the name Balboa Island is an island accessible to the public via bridges, ferries, and several public docks. With a population of only 2,221, Balboa Island is a small community with a high population density due to its small size. The quaint community is surrounded by a concrete pedestrian boardwalk that’s perfect for walking, biking, or running through the city.

The low crime rate paired with the excellent private and public schools in the area make Balboa Island an ideal location for families. Balboa Island is full of luxury homes and condominiums, cozy cottages, and bayfront homes with stunning views. If you’re looking for fun things to do, Balboa Island does not disappoint. Go parasailing 800 ft above the ocean, play a game or two at the Fun Zone at Balboa Village, or head onto the water for deep sea fishing, whale watching, a ride on a Sea Doo. For more information on Mission Viejo, visit the official Balboa Island city website.

Why owning rental property in Balboa Island is a good investment

Balboa Island is a prime location within Newport Beach that’s popular with both long-term residents and tourists. Its charm, proximity to the beach, and strong community atmosphere make it highly desirable, ensuring a steady stream of potential renters.

While there are no schools directly on Balboa Island, the area is part of the Newport-Mesa Unified School District that includes top-rated public schools like Harborview Elementary, Corona del Mar High School, and Tustin Hills Preparatory School.

Due to the island’s appeal and limited housing options, Balboa Island landlords often see higher-than-average rental rates and have a consistent rental income.

How much does Balboa Island property management cost?

Every Balboa Island property manager has their own unique fee structure, which can vary significantly from other property management companies in Newport Beach. At Good Life Property Management, we offer house, condo, and 2–4 unit property management for an 8% monthly management fee, with a reduced rate of 7% for properties renting over $6,000 per month. For multi-family properties (5–15 units), we offer a 6% monthly management fee. In addition to the monthly management fee, we charge a leasing fee equal to 25% of one month’s rent, a $150 annual inspection fee, and a $195 lease renewal fee.

Get all your questions answered by an expert for free

Megan Swartzentruber, Property Management Expert at Good Life Property Management

Megan Swartzentruber

DRE #02246430

Request a free consultation

By completing and submitting this form, I agree to receive marketing emails and SMS text messages from Good Life Property Management.

You can unsubscribe or update your preferences at any time. Your personal data will be processed in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

Home Prices

in Balboa Island

Balboa Island is one of the most sought-after areas in Orange County. Owning a property here offers prestige and can serve as an excellent long-term investment for those looking to enter a high-demand, upscale market. The island offers a unique combination of being close to the beach, offering beautiful views, and having access to a wide range of amenities like shops, restaurants, and recreational activities. This makes it an attractive place for people to live, vacation, or invest, driving both demand and property values.

Pros of Investing in Balboa Island

Balboa Island has historically shown strong property value growth and has a reputation for maintaining and even increasing property values over time. Add to that the unique, upscale lifestyle that Balboa Island offers—residents enjoy a relaxed atmosphere, picturesque views, and a wide variety of leisure activities. This created a stable and desirable rental market for investors.

Cons of Investing in Balboa Island

Because Balboa Island is one of the most desirable locations in Southern California, it comes with a premium price tag. Purchasing a property on the island can be significantly higher than in other nearby communities. Additionally, Balboa Island is relatively small, with limited space for development or new property listings. This creates a tight market, meaning there are fewer properties available for sale or rent which can make it difficult to enter the market.

Home Prices in Balboa Island

These are the year to date stats as of January 2025. For monthly stats, visit Redfin’s Balboa Island, CA Housing Market.
$3,921,250

The median price of a single-family home in Balboa Island, Newport Beach – 92662

Rental Rates in Balboa Island

These are the 2025 average rent prices in Balboa Island. For monthly stats, visit Zumper.
$49,953/month

The average rent for a 4-bedroom apartment in Balboa Island.

$13,235/month

The average rent for a 3-bedroom apartment in Balboa Island.

$4,486/month

The average rent for a 2-bedroom apartment in Balboa Island.

Good Life Promise

Real protection. Real Value. Real peace of mind.

Every lease comes backed by our highest standards – not just marketing fluff. Included in your protection plan:

Tenant Damage Coverage

We cover up to $3,500 in total reimbursement for physical damage, above the security deposit, caused by the tenant or their approved pet.

Eviction Protection

If a tenant we place needs to be evicted for any reason, not just nonpayment - we’ll cover up to $3,000 in court and legal fees, including attorney costs.

Releasing Support

If your tenant breaks their lease or is evicted within the first year, we’ll waive the leasing fee to find a qualified replacement -- at no cost to you.

Money back guarantee

Still unsure? Our six-month money-back commitment refunds up to 6 months of management fees if you’re not satisfied. No hassle, no hard feelings.

No long-term commitments

Stay because you want to, not because you have to. Month-to-month management with no long-term commitments required.

Risk and Fraud Protection

We protect your investment with rigorous tenant screening, secure payment systems, and proactive measures to minimize risk and prevent fraud.

Total Value:

over $10,000 in real, tangible protection.

See why 1000's of Property Owners & Realtors Trust us:

Orange County Property Management Blogs

How to Hire a Property Manager in OC? A family is working with a property manager.

How to Hire a Property Manager in Orange County: A Landlord’s Guide

Hiring a property manager in Orange County is one of the most consequential decisions you will make as a rental property owner. The market is tight and landlord-friendly, with vacancy around 4% to 4.5% and median rents near $4,000, which means the financial stakes of getting property management right (or wrong) are higher here than in most markets. Whether you are a first-time landlord renting out a single home or an investor expanding a portfolio, this guide will walk you through how to find, evaluate, and hire a property manager who actually earns the fee.

Read Full Article »